Whitefella Reflections on Closing the Gap

by | Nov 15, 2026 | Our Collective

FORCE OF LIFE PODCAST WITH MIK AIDT 

My name is Barbara Lepani. As co-host of the Force of Life Series with Mik Aidt of The Sustainable Hour, I am offering regular ‘Whitefella’ Reflections on the unfinished business concerning the relationship of non-Indigenous Australians, particularly those of us with Anglo-European ancestry like myself, with our Indigenous First Peoples.

Why? Because Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians are the living presence of Australia’s cultural foundations in the oldest continuous living culture in the world – dating back at least 65,000 years.

Its knowledge systems, anchored in the idea of Caring for Country, provide the deep and enduring foundation of our unique national identity. Not as an outpost of the British Empire. But as a multicultural nation of the South Pacific.

Reconciliation with Australia’s First Peoples is replete with misunderstandings. Even those of us motivated by concerns about equity and fairness, and who abhor racism, have little understanding of the profound differences between the underlying principles of our Indigenous cultural foundations and our own cultural assumptions.

CAPITALIST REALISM

Whitefella assumptions about what is ‘normal’ and ‘common sense’ are based on the logic of our own ‘Western’ knowledge system, which has achieved global dominance through economic globalisation, including the globalisation of tertiary education and research. Students from China, India and the Middle East have come to study at the great universities of the Western world: in the US, the UK, Australia, France, Germany etc, to learn the secrets of Western economic, technological and political power.

Some call this way of thinking Capitalist Realism, whereby it has become simply obvious that everything in society, including healthcare, aged care, childcare and education, should be run as a business. Where our homes have become financial assets. Why inter-generational social and spiritual distress has become private individual mental illness.

Capitalist Realism is why most people favour the idea of ‘practical reconciliation’ when addressing issues of Indigenous socio-economic distress. But this flies in the face of the true meaning of Caring for County.

CARING FOR COUNTRY

Caring for Country refers to a complete cosmology, a way of making sense of all of reality, not just about environmental management and conservation.

In the words of Elder, Aunty Sharyn Hall of the Blue Mountains:

Ngurra (Country) takes in everything within the cultural and spiritual landscape—landforms, trees, rocks, plants, animals, foods, medicine, minerals, stories and significant places. It includes cultural practices, knowledge, songs, stories and art as well as Spiritual Beings and people, present and future. Ngurra has a deep meaning of belonging.

These are encoded in the various songlines and sacred sites of the 250 different language groups that criss-cross Australia. They are the deep eco-spiritual veins of this land we call Australia. It speaks to us, but not in a human language. Listening to Country requires the ancient practice of dadirri—inner deep listening and quiet, still awareness. This requires heart-felt intuitive knowing, not the deductive rationality of capitalist realism.

WHO ARE INDIGENOUS AUSTRALIANS?

—Identity

As determined by accepted Australian Government policy, someone of Indigenous identity is any person of Aboriginal (or Torres Strait Islander) descent; who identifies as Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, and [importantly] who are accepted as such by the community in which they live. They constitute but 4% of the total population.

—Sovereignty

Many collectively refer to themselves as ‘blakfellas’, as distinguished from the rest of us as ‘whitefellas’, even though many also hold non-Indigenous ancestry. For them it is a question of cultural sovereignty and family connections, not skin colour.

Jason O’Neil, a Wiradjuri Legal Scholar from UNSW (referencing the work of historian Henry Reynolds) suggests that First Nations sovereignty remains the great unanswered question of Australia’s colonisation.

Sovereignty is often understood in international politics as the power to exercise supreme and unrivalled authority within a given territory, enshrined in constitutional law.

By contrast, Indigenous Australians claim a type of internal cultural sovereignty as distinct ‘political’ communities across their numerous language groups, while also pursuing their rights as equal citizens of Australia. Their leaders are not elected officials, but recognised Elders, the local Cultural Custodians of particular local communities.

The idea of cultural sovereignty within Australia exists alongside ‘Native Title’. It seeks to create the space for First Nations communities to protect their culture, law and traditions and to exercise autonomy with respect to matters that are important to them, such as economic development, land resource management, protection of cultural heritage and education.

Cultural Sovereignty is an important aspect of treaty negotiations, as have recently been secured in the Victorian State Parliament under the Statewide Treaty Act 2025. Gellung Warl (meaning “tip of the spear” in Gunaikurnai language) is the Treaty Authority overseeing treaty negotiations in Victoria.

Both the Coalition Liberal-National Parties and One Nation Party have promised to abolish The Treaty Act if they secure a governing majority in the November 2026 elections.

—Background

No Treaty was ever signed between the British Crown as the occupying colonial power and Australia’s First Peoples. Indigenous peoples were not granted equal citizenship under the Constitution until after the 1967 Referendum. Indigenous land rights were not recognised till 1976, and only in the Northern Territory. It would not be until 1993 that the Federal Government passed the Native Titles Act, which has given Indigenous Australians the legal means to reclaim title to their lands, where they still exist as Crown Land, and are not held under individual title by Australian citizens in cities, towns, and farms.

WHITEFELLA  AUSTRALIANS

The term ‘Whitefella’ refers to all non-Indigenous Australians who subscribe to the assumptions and values that underpin modern Australia.

These operate under the legal framework of the Australian Constitution, enacted in 1901 by the Anglo-Celtic settler population, and the subsequent laws and policies of various levels of government (Federal, State and Local) that have shaped modern Australia for the last 240+ years. These also inform the citizenship requirements of Multicultural Australia, which has welcomed people of many ethnicities and religious faith traditions.

—Being a Whitefella

I am of Anglo-Celtic and Danish ancestry, dating back to earlier colonial times. I grew up in regional Queensland. In 1971, I married a fellow UNSW student from the Trobriand Islands of PNG, and lived in PNG during the time it transitioned to self-government and independence in the 1970s. I am the mother of bi-racial children with strong ties to their Father’s country and culture, while at the same time living in Australia as Australian citizens.

I also spent a year working with Aboriginal Yankunytjatjara Elder, Bob Randall, on his autobiography, published as Songman in 2003.

I therefore have some understanding of being a whitefella working and living across the colonial and cultural divide. Professionally I am also a product of the logics of ‘whitefella’ education, working in public policy as a sociologist of technological change. In addition, although I was brought up in the Christian Faith, and became an agnostic humanist in my youth, since my mid-thirties I have been a student-practitioner in the Tibetan Buddhist tradition, which has its own ancient knowledge system.

All these threads have helped me gain some perspective on the nature and limits of ‘whitefella reality’ and the limitations of ‘capitalist realism’ when considering the question of truly understanding our nation’s foundations in the world’s oldest living culture and its ancient eco-spiritual wisdom.

CLOSING THE GAP

—Closing the Socio-Economic Gap

Like it or not, we all live in the world shaped by our dominant economic and judicial system enshrined in the Australian Constitution. People of Indigenous ancestry experience high levels of socio-economic distress across all measures of modern Australian life: life expectancy, educational attainment, employment, income, housing, family breakdown, incarceration, and being the subject of enduring racialised marginalisation and abuse. According to the Australian Resilience Index, a great many also feel like strangers in their own land: that they do not belong in modern Australia. To address such socio-economic distress, the Australian Parliament initiated a bi-partisan Closing the Gap strategy in 2020.

This is designed to improve the socio-economic conditions of Indigenous people, measured against the markers of success in the dominant ‘whitefella’ culture of a modern capitalist society: health status and longevity; educational participation and attainment; economic participation through employment and business; and access to suitable, affordable housing.

These issues of equity and fairness are important to address, and are what people mean by the idea of ‘practical reconciliation’.

—Closing the Knowledge Gap

The Closing the Gap strategy, however, does not explicitly recognise the knowledge gap that separates modern Australia from the principles underling Australia’s foundational culture and its enduring knowledge systems. As Distinguished Law Professor Larissa Behrendt notes when trying to explain why past ‘practical reconciliation’ strategies have failed to work:

“There has never been a moment in Australia’s history when the underlying purpose of these institutions was consciously dismantled and reimagined. Instead, the structures have been modernised, refined and rebranded – but never fundamentally transformed.”

As a result of the practices of British colonial settlement, many Indigenous languages were forcibly suppressed, cultural practices banned, and denied the underlying knowledge system any value or legitimacy. For this reason, it has been difficult for non-Indigenous people to gain an understanding of this important knowledge and cultural foundation, with previous works mainly produced by non-Indigenous anthropologists and cultural historians.

To address this knowledge gap between modern ‘whitefella’ Australia and our cultural foundations, I argue that Closing the Gap should work both ways.

It should recognise the unique contribution that Indigenous knowledge systems, with markedly different principles to those that govern modern society, could make to the many complex issues facing modern Australia. It is not about romanticising Indigenous culture and community life. It is about recognising the enduring wisdom of relational reciprocity, which is embedded in Indigenous knowledge systems under the all-embracing ethos of ‘Caring for Country’, with its multiple levels of meaning.

As revealed in the political debate and outcome of the 2023 Referendum on an Indigenous Voice to Parliament, this lack of understanding plays out in the political debate between political leaders such as Senator Jacinta Nampijinpa Price, who argues for an assimilationist approach for the future of First Nations People (we are all one people and colonisation has been good for us) and those such as Senator Pat Dodson and Dr Yunupingu, who have argued for the continued support of a living Indigenous culture that is different from mainstream Australia. Core to this support is the idea of Indigenous Cultural Sovereignty.

INDIGENOUS KNOWLEDGE SYSTEMS

The contribution of Indigenous Australians to Australia’s cultural sector and its international representation has been enormous—in visual art, music, literature and the performing arts. The Yolnu people of East Arnhem Land have been particularly active in this space through the Garma Festival, as have cultural institutions such as Bangarra Dance Theatre, based in Sydney, and Marrugeku’s Trans-Indigenous and Intercultural Theatre, based in Broome and Perth.

But the penetration of these insights into a different way of ‘seeing, thinking and doing’ by mainstream ‘whitefella’ Australia has been weak, even among those passionately committed to Reconciliation. To address this knowledge gap, many Indigenous scholars have been working with their cultural custodians to find ways to explain its core principles to those shaped by mainstream whitefella culture.

In particular, I would recommend the First Knowledges Series, edited by Margo Neale, Indigenous Curator at the National Museum of Australia. Co-authored by Indigenous and non-Indigenous scholars, the series covers the following topics: Law, Ceremony, Songlines, Astronomy, Country, Innovation, Design, Health and Plants. Law: The Way of the Ancestors is the place to start. As the whitefella historian Henry Reynolds says, “No other current work has been able to so comprehensively explain the significance of traditional law in all its manifestations.”

Another important publication with a focus on Indigenous Knowledges, Songspirals: Sharing Women’s Wisdom of Country through Songlines, was a co-production between a group of Yolnu knowledge holders in East Arnhem Land and three non-Indigenous cultural geographers, who worked together over a period of 10 years.

As award winning historian, Clare Wright says: ‘To read Songspirals is to change the way you see, think and feel this country.’

It is this shift, which lies at the heart of closing this knowledge Gap in the way all Australians, especially the non-Indigenous Australians who comprise 96% of the total population, can come to understand the true cultural foundations of Australia.

—Understanding Indigenous Knowledge Foundations

The richness of Indigenous knowledge systems, with its ethos of relational reciprocity across all systems, is now being reclaimed and articulated in various publications and forums through the research work of a range of Indigenous academics working in Australian Universities in collaboration with traditional knowledge custodians in different Indigenous language groups.

Examples include:

  • Deakin University – Indigenous Knowledge Systems Lab
  • University of Melbourne– Indigenous Knowledges Institute
  • University of Notre Dame—Nulungu Research Institute
  • Macquarie University – Relational Futures Research Project
  • University of Sydney – Indigenous Studies Program
  • UTS – Indigenous-Led Knowledges and Research
  • UNSW – Nura Gili: Centre for Indigenous Programs
  • Western Sydney University—Indigenous Centre of Excellence
  • University of Wollongong – Woolyungah Indigenous Centre
  • Charles Sturt University—School of Indigenous Australian Studies
  • University of Western Australia – School of Indigenous Studies
  • Murdoch University – School of Indigenous Knowledges
  • Charles Darwin University – Indigenous Knowledges
  • Griffith University – Indigenous Research Unit
  • QUT– Faculty of Indigenous Knowledges & Culture
  • James Cook University—Indigenous Education and Research Centre

All these centres of Indigenous knowledges research regularly release published articles, and provide related insights through various media: film, documentaries, podcasts, YouTube, public events, Facebook, etc.

They are part of a global movement among Indigenous peoples, particularly across the Pacific, including New Zealand and Australia, Canada, US, Central and South America, Africa and the Arctic. They are motivated by the real possibility of ecological collapse across many parts of the world under the impact of capitalist realism, in all its forms: democracy, authoritarianism, oligarchic fascism.

—The Modernity/Coloniality Complex

Of particular importance has been the work of Victoria University in Canada, led by Professor Vanessa Oliveira Andreotti with her landmark publication on the modernity/coloniality complex: Hospicing Modernity: Facing Humanity’s Wrongs and the Implications for Social Activism. This is an excellent place for any ‘whitefella’ to start with understanding how whitefella ways of thinking are part of the problem, as we try to come to grips with the many complex issues of our times.

“Modernity is a single story of progress, development, human evolution and civilisation that is omnipresent. Modernity is full of paradoxes: of war and humanitarian support, of ongoing colonialism and reconciliation, of imperialism and education, of poverty creation and alleviation, of exponential growth and sustainability. Whether you and I identify with or are critical of it, it still conditions what and how we think, feel, desire, relate, hope and imagine.”

“Our collective unconscious knows that the enjoyments and securities promised by modernity cannot be endlessly sustained. This book is about preparing ourselves for coexisting differently, whenever these enjoyments and securities may be taken away, whether this will happen in our lifetimes.”

THE GREAT TRANSITION

We are aware that the world is going through a great transformation. Climate change and environmental degradation are forcing us to recognise that humans have breached the bio-regional sustainability of the Earth’s living systems.

As UN secretary-general, António Guterres, says:

“You cannot build peace on a burning planet,” he said. “You cannot eradicate poverty when climate disasters keep throwing people back into it. You cannot promise young people a better future while destroying the natural systems on which that future depends. And you cannot speak seriously about justice when those who did least to cause this crisis suffer first and worst.”

We are in the midst of attempts to undertake a great energy transition from fossil fuels to renewable energies in order to contain the ecological collapse that threatens our future generations. To repair the environmental destruction of our waterways and soils. To halt the level of species extinctions across the natural world.

We are also in the midst of the end of the era of Anglo-European economic, political and cultural dominance. The old rules-based international order under Pax Americana no longer holds. China, not the US, is leading the energy transition—dominating in all forms of clean tech, and fast catching the US in the development of AI technologies.

But behind this story of technological competition and clean tech, lies a more important story.

Not just a story of overcoming the level of wealth inequality that is currently tearing the very underpinnings of social democracies apart.

It is a more profound and deeper story. A story that will allow us to transition away from a dream of profligate material wealth at the expense of the natural world, which has been a profound betrayal of the eco-spiritual laws of the interdependent nature of phenomenological reality that governs us all. What Australia’s First Nations peoples call, The Law: The Way of the Ancestors.

Catalogue OF Articles by Barbara Lepani July 2018-Present

Recent Comments

    CONNECT TO THE BUZZ

    SUBSCRIBE TO THE ENLIVENMENT FEED

    Subscribe to our email lists to receive the latest Blog Posts or our Monthly Newsletter, or both, emailed directlt to your indox.

    Just fill in the form below.